Score: 8

"Its a good song..."

submission: I Like to Hit Things

date: March 3, 2008

But, there are some problems. I noticed that the style doesn't change even in the slow parts. It's always staccato, and there's no real change in dynamics, maybe a decrescendo into mezzo piano around 1:00, keeping the bass at the same volume, then at about 1:15 to 1:33 or so, a crescendo to forte with the bass crescendo starting at around 1:23. Near 1:55 to 2:02, decrescendo the treble to mezzo piano and the bass to mezzo forte, then raise the bass to fortissimo at 2:03 and dropping it gradually from 2:18 to piano at 2:30 with the treble dropping to pianissimo around the same point. Then, at 2:36, a crescendo again to fortissimo for both, and at 3:02, make a sfortzando and start Section A again (the happy part) and bring it back up to the original forte. After that, whatever the heck you want to be there. Maybe another key change, possibly a meter change to 3/4 time! Also, I think it belongs where you originally put it: the classical section. There's no real elements of jazz in there (no swing beat, no blues scales, etc.) if you think about it. Great song, and a dl once you finish it!

Score: 9

"really does sound like a sonic song"

submission: -WritersBlock-Leap Of Faith

date: February 21, 2008

in fact, you could make it part of Sonic 4!

Score: 10

"Good set of songs!"

submission: Carnival of Forgotten DreamsWB

date: February 21, 2008

I think it would sound really awesome if you found a way to link them all together into one song and transition each one into the next. Maybe even send that to NG

Score: 9

"Yet again..."

submission: Sonic 1 Marble Zone Remix

date: February 12, 2008

You seem to like long intros, don't you? ANYWAY... I think the synth for the main melody should be maybe an octave lower, you know? Also, you should take out the clangy noise on the second time you do the melody. At least lower it. Still 9&4 but no dl.

Score: 9

"Ive gotta play that game again."

submission: Aqua Duo

date: February 9, 2008

Thing is, the stupid thing's too hard. To get back on topic, I liked the music, but it was a little too short. Also, I can't believe I'm saying this, but... it sounded too much like it was actually from the game. By that, I mean that, well, I usually look for VG music that sounds more realistic, you know?

Score: 10

"sounds like it was made for the show"

submission: Rig - What if? (Genesis Redux)

date: February 5, 2008

the main background melody is almost the same as the opening act, making it perfect to go with the rest of it. another 5d & 10d

Score: 10

"YES! FINALLY!!!"

submission: Rig - What if? (Opening Act)

date: February 4, 2008

A great song man. And I've finally found what I've been looking for: live DnB. That's sort of what I'm trying to do for all my techno. When I get something submitted, think you could come listen? *Thinks to himself: finally i found something live!*

Score: 10

"If only they had this genre..."

submission: Turn of Tides

date: February 4, 2008

I'd tell you to put it on this if the genre was actually on the NGAP, but sadly it isn't: Symphonic Techno. Man that'd be awesome!

Score: 7

"It's pretty good."

submission: S3&K PC - Launch Base Act 1

date: January 15, 2008

I can't believe that Sonic Team replaced the masterpiece BGM known as Launch Base Zone with this idiocy! (Original tune, remix is okay) When I saw this on the listings I expected this to be a remix of that song with the "GO! GO! GO!" in the background, you know?

Score: 10

"Try..."

submission: Sonic Heroes | Hang Castle

date: January 15, 2008

Hang Castle Zone 2 (Upside down thing). I always liked that one a little better, cause, you know, heavier.